The Practical Lawyer


Lease to family – not a relevant disposal

Under s1(1) LTA 1987 L shall not make a ‘relevant disposal affecting any premises to which at the time of the disposal this Part applies’ unless it has previously served notice in accordance with s5 on ‘the qualifying tenants of the flats contained in those premises’ and the disposal is made in accordance with the requirements of ss6-10. The 1987 Act gives ‘leaseholders of residential flats in a block of flats improved rights to control the upkeep and maintenance of the block as a whole, by conferring on Ts a right of first refusal when L is proposing to dispose of his reversion’.

The HC has recently considered these provisions. York House is a purpose-built block of 42 flats in Chelsea comprising a basement, ground floor and eight upper floors. The development potential is significant. The freehold is owned by the defendants. 41 of the flats are demised on long leases – some of the long lessees were planning to claim the freehold under LRHUDA 1993. The defendants were concerned that the price payable under the 1993 Act would not properly reflect the development value. Accordingly, the defendants granted 14 leases of various parts of York House and the surrounding area to one or other of themselves. There was no premium payable and the rent reserved was a peppercorn.

The defendants did not serve the s5 notices on the qualifying Ts under LTA 1987 prior to granting the 14 leases. It was accepted that LTA 1987 applied to York House but HC had to determine whether the long leases created by the defendants were ‘relevant disposals’ which would give the claimants the right to acquire the leases.

The claimants came up with an ingenious argument – that the creation of a new tenancy could not constitute a ‘gift’ because the grant of a lease necessarily entails the tenant incurring contractual obligations towards L, sufficient to constitute consideration, which prevents the grant of the lease from constituting a gift. Even where a lease contains no express tenant’s covenants, at least some will be implied. The HC did not accept this argument and held that the 14 leases were ‘gifts to a member of L’s family’ and, as such, were not ‘relevant disposals’ so no s5 notices were required and the claimant could not compel the defendants to transfer the leases under the 1987 Act. See York House v Thompson [2019] EWHC 2203 (Ch) and reported on


Most-read articles

Intestacy – statutory legacy
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
The statutory legacy under the intestacy rules has increased to £270,000 with effect from 6 February 2020. It’s the first increase since October 2014. Read more...
Unsolicited publicity – SRA guidance
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
Some practitioners were somewhat aghast to read para 8.9 in the new Code of Conduct for solicitors as follows: Read more...
Part 36 offer – includes interest
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
Part 36 is a provision of the CPR which is intended to encourage parties to settle disputes without going to trial. A Part 36 offer made by either the claimant or defendant is a tactical step... Read more...
Slipping claims – burden of proof
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
In general, the law on slipping cases is reasonably settled and straightforward. An interesting article considers a question which often arises in practice, namely whether the defendant bears an... Read more...
MEES – domestic rentals reminder
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
We last reported on the MEES Regulations in our May 2019 edition (p24). The Domestic Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard (MEES) Regulations set a minimum energy efficiency level for domestic private... Read more...
Lease to family – not a relevant disposal
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
Under s1(1) LTA 1987 L shall not make a ‘relevant disposal affecting any premises to which at the time of the disposal this Part applies’ unless it has previously served notice in accordance with... Read more...
Oral trust for third party – not binding
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
A recent CC decision is an important reminder to property practitioners to advise clients to ensure that any declaration of trust is in writing. Section 53(1)(b) LPA 1925 states that: Read more...
Civil partnerships – opposite sex
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
The Civil Partnership (Opposite-sex Couples) Regulations came into force on 2 December 2019 enabling mixed-sex couples to enter into a civil partnership, as an alternative to marriage or cohabitation. Read more...
Ethical veganism – a philosophical belief
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
A vegan is someone who does not eat or use animal products. 'Ethical' veganism is more than just not eating or using animal products – it goes beyond this in that ethical vegans try to exclude all... Read more...
Stalking – orders
Wednesday, 12 February 2020
The perpetrators of stalking can now be banned from approaching and/or contacting their victims under police powers that came into force on 20 January 2020. Under the Stalking Protection Act 2019,... Read more...


IAG International
In House Lawyer
Join the IBA now!
MSI Global Alliance